Technology
Speediness Isn't The Same For All Physicians
Studying landmark guidelines for the use of coronary stents, researchers explore how quickly physicians respond to and apply new information in their line of work.
Jul 24, 2018

Speediness Isn't The Same For All Physicians

Depending On Expertise, Physicians Vary In How Quickly They Adopt New Information

Jul 24, 2018
Technology
As Featured In 
Organization Science

How do high-performing organizations learn and adapt their routines and procedures? Do they look to constantly bring new information into their processes? Are they quick to adopt new ways of doing things at the individual and organizational levels?

Researchers at the University of Maryland’s Robert H. Smith School of Business sought to answer those questions, examining not only individuals within the organization, but also how the interplay between organizational and individual characteristics enhances or inhibits assimilation of newly available information.

Their study focused on the treatment of coronary arterial disease, examining how organizations and professionals would adapt amid new multi-level information diffusion. The information was the introduction of a landmark 2006 guideline for the use of coronary stents, issued by the American Heart Association and the American College of Cardiology, which recommended limiting stents for low severity heart disease patients.

The researchers empirically examined how individual physicians with different types of expertise — some general and some specialized — vary in the speed they adopt the new information.

They studied spillovers in learning as well, finding that organizations that responded swiftly to new information typically possessed expert physicians, and were also subject to intra-organizational externalities through peer effects. “Using quantitative and qualitative approaches, we find both individual and organizational expertise affects changes in practice,” they wrote.

The research reveals that experts who had deliberate practice tended to react faster to new information. Those with more general forms of expertise, such as tenure or elite education, meanwhile, didn’t exhibit such responses.

The researchers say their findings may have applications in other fields, such as education, law and consulting, where intensive knowledge work and complex technology play prominent roles. They caution, however, that the results should be interpreted cautiously, because of the potential influence of other outside factors.

“Theoretically, we believe this interplay between macro-level organizational factors that create an environment conducive for learning and adaptation, and micro-level human capital that enables individuals to respond positively within such organizational environments, is a more nuanced, and ultimately more precise, depiction of how learning takes place within fast-moving institutionalized fields.”

Ritu Agarwal, senior associate dean for research, and the Robert H. Smith Dean’s Chair of Information Systems at the Smith School, says the latest research could hold “significant implications” for the medical profession. Agarwal, who authored the paper with Smith School colleagues Rajshree Agarwal and Anandasivam Gopal, and the University of Minnesota’s Brad N. Greenwood, is also the the founder and director of the Smith School’s Center for Health Information and Decision Systems.

Adherence to guidelines significantly improves clinical care outcomes, so the researchers surmised that the appropriate reaction, from an economic perspective, should be “an immediate and sharp drop in the stenting rate.” The researchers concluded, therefore, that the fact that the response across agents of all levels of expertise was not immediate did present cause for concern.

In fact, they computed the economic burden of the relatively slow response. They assumed that the 3.5 percent stenting rate for low-severity SCAD patients in 2010 was stable, meaning that roughly 35,500 patients in the sample would have been subjected to unnecessary stenting procedures. At $17,000 per procedure, that would translate to an avoidable burden of roughly $603 million in the state of Florida. Given how pervasive SCAD and the practice of stenting are, the costs associated with the delay would be substantial, likely reaching into the tens of billions of dollars.

“While our study focused on changes in organizational routines in a single domain, examples of physician non-compliance or slow compliance with medical guidelines are pervasive,” the researchers say.

For example, fewer than 40 percent of women diagnosed with ovarian cancer in the U.S. receive care that complies with guidelines, which significantly increases their risk of death. And in fact, treatments for numerous medical conditions, from cholesterol to breast cancer, exhibit physician non-compliance with medical guidelines.

“A clear implication of our study is that deliberate practice is an enabler; the presence of such experts in organizations is instrumental in not only preventing needless spending, but also avoiding potential loss of health and even life associated with poor adherence to medical guidelines,” the researchers say.

The increase in the number of specialists in medicine at perhaps the expense of medical students selecting into general practice has been treated as a matter of some concern, the researchers note. “Our results provide some evidence for the benefits of increasing specialization and the role of experts as influencers,” they write. “Indeed, some physicians from our qualitative sample stated their hospitals now mandate that their physicians be board certified in their sub-specialty in order to have admitting privileges.”

Read more: The Role of Individual and Organizational Expertise in Adoption of New Practices is featured in Organization Science.

About the Author(s)

Ritu Agarwal

Ritu Agarwal is interim dean of the Robert H. Smith School of Business at the University of Maryland. She is also the Robert H. Smith Dean’s Chair of Information Systems and founding director of the school’s Center for Health Information and Decision Systems (CHIDS). She has published more than 100 papers in top academic journals, testified before government agencies such as the U.S. Department of Health, and collaborated with Fortune 500 companies such as Cisco Systems, Johnson and Johnson and Pfizer. Since arriving at Maryland Smith in 1999, Agarwal has taught at every level and received all of the school’s major teaching awards. Prior to her appointment as interim dean, she served as Senior Associate Dean for Faculty & Research.

Rajshree Agarwal

Rajshree Agarwal is the Rudolph P. Lamone Chair and Professor in Entrepreneurship at the University of Maryland and director of the Ed Snider Center for Enterprise and Markets. Rajshree’s research interests focus on the implications of entrepreneurship and innovation for industry and firm evolution. Her recent projects examine the micro-foundations of macro phenomena, linking knowledge diffusion among firms, industries, and regions to the underlying mechanisms of employee entrepreneurship and mobility.

Anandasivam Gopal

Anand Gopal is a Professor and Van Munching Faculty Fellow at the Robert H. Smith School of Business, University of Maryland. His research interests are broadly in technology platforms, contracts and entrepreneurship. He has specific projects in technology-based entrepreneurship, secondary markets for tech products, mobile platforms and healthcare.

More in

Technology

Want People To Use Bike Shares? Don’t Make Them Walk.
In cities around the globe, it seems like bike and electric scooter rentals are everywhere. But if one isn’t in the right place when a person needs it, they aren’t going to walk out of their way to find one.
Dec 03, 2019
How To Make More Money in Online Auctions
To attract more online auction bidders and drive up prices, two things matter: how long an auction is active and the day of the week it closes, finds new research.
Nov 21, 2019
How Social Networks Can Curb Youth Unemployment
A powerful tool for curbing the growing worldwide problem of youth unemployment could be the ubiquitous mobile phone found in most teens’ pockets, finds new research.
Aug 22, 2019