Technology
Neutralizing Speedy New Entry Threats
Incumbent IT firms could respond with higher investment in research and development, but most don’t.
Feb 01, 2019

Neutralizing Speedy New Entry Threats

Incumbent IT Firms Could Respond with Higher R&D Spending, But Most Don’t

Feb 01, 2019
Technology
As Featured In 
Information Systems Research

Information technology firms can never rest. Speedy startups constantly emerge from the entrepreneurial ecosystem with novel products and services. One strategic response could be preemptive investment in research and development. But a new study from the University of Maryland’s Robert H. Smith School of Business shows the opposite usually occurs.

“Incumbent IT firms on average reduce their R&D spending when they face high new entry threats,” authors Yang Pan, Peng Huang and Anandasivam Gopal write Information Systems Research. Pan, a professor at Louisiana State University, is a Maryland Smith PhD alumna, while her co-authors are professors at Maryland Smith.

Prior research has produced contradictory predictions about the response to new entry threats in the IT space, where fast clock-speed drives economic growth.

“Some may choose to increase their investments in R&D, in the hope of establishing advantage in technological and process capabilities,” the authors write.

On the other hand, incumbents may hold off on R&D spending, where the payoffs are uncertain.

“They may choose, instead, to either conserve their cash in anticipation of acquiring technology licensing later from pioneers, or invest in complementary capabilities like marketing, distribution and manufacturing that can help the incumbent compete more effectively should the anticipated threats materialize,” the authors write.

To draw their conclusions, the authors first had to develop a valid instrument for measuring threats from new entrants. Such an instrument has remained elusive, largely because the central question involves speculation about future activity.

Researchers must quantify threats that don’t yet exist, but may materialize later. “Notwithstanding the importance of new entry threats in theoretical work, the absence of an established measure represents a significant gap in the literature,” Pan, Huang and Gopal write.

The authors tackled the challenge using text mining. They started with product descriptions filed by incumbent firms with the Securities and Exchange Commission from 1997 to 2013, and then looked for overlapping words and phrases in business descriptions of entrepreneurial ventures that received first-round funding from venture capitalists during the same period.

“The presence of VC funding makes them credible threats, while also signaling quality,” the authors write.

Many startups at the first-round stage are still years away from selling products or services. But several tests confirm the validity of the instrument developed by the authors.

Related insights also emerged. “We show that firms facing high new entry threats are likely to experience greater turbulence in the forms of layoffs and bankruptcies in the future, dynamics consistent with prior theory,” the authors write.

Read more: Storm Clouds on the Horizon? New Entry Threats and R&D Investments in the U.S. IT Industry, by Yang Pan, Peng Huang and Anandasivam Gopal, Information Systems Research.

About the Author(s)

Anandasivam Gopal

Anand Gopal is a Professor and Van Munching Faculty Fellow at the Robert H. Smith School of Business, University of Maryland. His research interests are broadly in technology platforms, contracts and entrepreneurship. He has specific projects in technology-based entrepreneurship, secondary markets for tech products, mobile platforms and healthcare.

HuangPeng

Peng Huang is an assistant professor in the Decisions, Operations and Information Technologies Department at the Robert H. Smith School of Business at the University of Maryland. His research interests include: 1) platform-based information technology and innovation ecosystem in the enterprise software industry; 2) how consumers search for information and make decisions in the context of electronic commerce, and its implication for public policy and firm strategy. His research has appeared or is forthcoming in premier scholarly journals such as Management Science, MIS Quarterly, and Journal of Marketing. His work received the Runner-Up Best Conference Paper Award at the 2009 International Conference on Information Systems.

More in

Technology

The Pros and Cons of Open Source
New Maryland Smith research presents an economic model to study how software licensing attributes affect a software maker’s decisions, along with insights for policymakers.
Apr 09, 2019
Why There's An App For That
A new study examines what happens when a platform owner enters the market with a product that directly competes against rivals in the app store. Does it help or hurt innovation?
Mar 05, 2019
A Tool for Closing the Gender Pay Gap
Equal pay for equal work is a simple notion, but surprisingly hard to implement without buy-in from upper management and quantitative tools for decision support.
Feb 28, 2019